Looking back: How I came to Question

A loved one just called to arrange a time for us to talk.  I'm looking forward to it, but - I couldn't help but wonder if there was an ulterior motive behind the call.  After all, I recently announced I'm moving in with my boyfriend.  Is it possible this is an attempt to talk some sense into me?  Frankly I don't mind, because these are usually the talks that allow me to express my view of things too.  I'm in favor of more open communication, which means the vocalization of different points of view. 

So, accepting the invitation led me on a trip down memory lane.  I started thinking about all the issues that added up and gave me the courage to finally question and then (5 minutes later) reject Mormonism.  If I were to make a roughly chronological list, I would say my deconversion was mostly facilitated by the following:
  • My recognition that Mormonism preached "ye shall know them by their fruits," but failed to boast significantly more of the "good fruits" than other religions
  • My secret admission (post-mission) that I'd prefer the eternal company of lots of people not interested in Mormonism over many Mormons and investigators
  • My low opinion of the morality/maturity of the average single Mormon man in comparison with those outside of the church (for example, one of my gay friends who left the church was just head and shoulders above many of my active male peers in overall goodness)
  • My inability to reconcile the idea of a god who preferred his children to stay single if a temple-worthy spouse was not to be found with a god who 1) wanted his children to learn by having families, and 2) would command a prophet (Hosea) to marry a harlot 
  • My education in theories of learning, which led me to recognize Mormonism theology as based on behaviorism - a manipulative mode of learning (why would god choose to base his religion on such a qualitatively and morally inferior mode of learning?)
  • My frustration with the disproportionate focus on striving for personal perfection versus actively working for peace in the world
  • My perception of a general sense of self-loathing and eternal inadequacy within myself and among many of my most faithful friends and a belief that such was not healthy or consistent with the happiness promised from living the gospel
  • My realization that so many prophets in the Book of Mormon and other scriptures were self-righteous
  • My recognition that Joseph Smith was emotionally manipulative
  • My disbelief in a god who would EVER allow his prophets (eg. Brigham Young) to fuel racism
  • My disbelief in a god who would simultaneously endorse agency and discourage access to multiple points of view (wasn't the war in heaven supposed to have started with a two-sided debate?)
  • My growing understanding of how the brain works

5 comments:

Measure said...

This got me thinking about the steps leading to my deconversion process...

-Learned while still a teenager that most church policies were set by politics, not revelation

-Learned on my mission that the church is not necessarily the best path to happiness for everybody

-Started leaning libertarian in my late 20's, could not find any logical reason outside of religion to support opposition to gay marriage

-When I was about 31, read a book about evolution and learned that God was *not* necessary to explain the world

-Within a year after that, I read an argument against the existence of God I could not logically or emotionally refute.

-Upon reading that argument, went from Believing Mormon to Atheist Mormon in the space of a few minutes.

-Tried to find a way to regain my faith... but everything I tried just crushed it further.

-Stopped attending church at the age of 32.

simplysarah said...

Wow, that's a great story! Thanks for sharing. Everyone has an interesting path that is uniquely their own. I hope more will share...

Reuben said...

Good luck with your discussion. I hope it is productive and encourages the two of you to grow closer together. I enjoyed reading this list you've put together - I can identify with many of the items on this list.

Andrew said...

I have a pretty similar list as to why I left evangelicalism. I think some of my Mormon friends see my departure from Evangelicalism as an opportunity to get me to go native... but as much as Mormons and Evangelicals claim to be SO different, I cannot help but see glaring similarities.

miriam said...

You are very smart, logical and express yourself well. These are all VALID reasons to leave. I too dropped the church easier and quicker than I expected once I allowed myself to question.